Why You Need a Lawyer to Prepare Your Will: Lessons from Recent Case Law

Why You Need a Lawyer to Prepare Your Will: Lessons from Recent Case Law

The decision to prepare your Will is one of the most important steps you can take to protect your loved ones’ future. While online templates and do-it-yourself options might seem appealing, recent court cases highlight why working with a qualified lawyer is essential for creating a valid and enforceable will.

The Hidden Complexities of Will Creation

At first glance, writing a Will might appear straightforward – simply stating who gets what after you’re gone. However, the legal requirements for a valid Will are far more nuanced than most people realize. Without proper legal guidance, even minor oversights can lead to significant problems:

• Unclear language that causes family disputes
• Technical errors that could invalidate the entire Will
• Overlooked legal requirements for signing and witnessing
• Insufficient evidence of testamentary capacity

The Power of Legal Expertise: Insights from Kates Estate

A 2020 Ontario Superior Court case, illustrates why having a lawyer prepare your Will is crucial. In this landmark decision, Justice Arthur Gans ruled on a contested Will where questions arose about the testator’s mental capacity to make changes to her Will.

Despite concerns raised by medical professionals about Ms. Kates’ mental state, the court ultimately upheld the Will’s validity. Why? Because her lawyer had maintained detailed records and could testify about her mental capacity when making the changes. As Justice Gans emphasized in his ruling:

“The evidence of the drafting solicitor who had met with and spoken repeatedly with the testator should be preferred over all else, even that of medical professionals.”

Why a Lawyer’s Role Matters

Working with a lawyer to prepare your will offers several critical advantages that DIY solutions simply cannot match:

1. Professional Documentation

• Lawyers maintain detailed records of meetings and discussions
• These records become crucial evidence if the Will is ever challenged
• Professional documentation helps prove testamentary capacity

2. Legal Expertise

• Ensures compliance with all legal requirements
• Uses precise language to prevent misinterpretation
• Addresses complex situations like blended families or business assets
• Helps avoid common pitfalls that could invalidate the will

3. Protection Against Challenges

• Lawyer’s testimony carries significant weight in court
• Professional oversight helps prevent successful contests
• Reduces the risk of family disputes and litigation

The High Cost of DIY Wills

While creating a Will without legal assistance might save money initially, it often leads to costly problems:

• Family conflicts due to unclear instructions
• Extended probate processes
• Expensive legal battles to resolve disputes
• Potential invalidation of the entire Will
• Unintended distribution of assets.

Making the Right Choice

The case identified earlier in this post demonstrates that having a lawyer prepare your Will isn’t just about legal documentation – it’s about creating a robust shield that protects your wishes and your beneficiaries’ interests. When your Will is challenged, your lawyer becomes a crucial witness who can testify about your mental capacity and intentions at the time of drafting.

Conclusion

While DIY options might seem convenient and cost-effective, they can’t replace the expertise and protection that comes with professional legal guidance. Your Will is too important to leave to chance. By working with a qualified lawyer, you’re not just creating a legal document – you’re investing in your family’s future security and peace of mind.

Don’t let the desire to save money today create expensive problems for your loved ones tomorrow. Contact a qualified legal professional to ensure your will accurately reflects your wishes and stands up to potential challenges. We would also like to add that we do feel the DIY approach to a Will is a great start, particularly for people who are not established in life without children and or even homes. Why would they need a Will?  Well, items like savings accounts, RRSPs, and insurance policies implemented with a first job all require careful planning and appropriate identification of beneficiaries to make sure that they reflect the individual’s wants and wishes.

International Estate Planning: Why Your Estate Plan Needs to Go Global