When drafting a will in Ontario, the terms “Issue” and “Children” carry distinct legal meanings that significantly impact how assets are distributed. Understanding these differences is critical to ensuring your estate plan aligns with your intentions, especially when dealing with giftover clauses (where a gift passes to another beneficiary if the original recipient predeceases the testator).
1. What Do These Terms Mean?
- Children: Refers only to a person’s direct biological or legally adopted offspring (first generation). Stepchildren are excluded unless formally adopted.
- Issue: Encompasses all lineal descendants, including children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, and beyond.
2. Implications for Giftover Clauses
Giftover clauses determine who inherits if a named beneficiary dies before the testator. The choice between “issue” and “children” here is pivotal:
| Term Used | Scope of Beneficiaries | Example Scenario |
|---|---|---|
| “Children” | Only the beneficiary’s direct offspring (no grandchildren or remoter descendants). | If a son predeceases the testator, only his children (not grandchildren) inherit his share. |
| “Issue” | All descendants of the beneficiary, including grandchildren, great-grandchildren, etc. | If a daughter predeceases, her share passes to her children, and if they’re deceased, to their children. |
3. Key Considerations for Testators
- Clarity Is Crucial: Courts generally interpret “children” narrowly and “issue” broadly. To avoid ambiguity:
- Define terms explicitly in the will.
- Use examples or a “dictionary” section to clarify intentions.
- Stepchildren and Adopted:
- Stepchildren are not automatically included as “children” or “issue” unless legally adopted.
- Adopted children are treated as biological under Ontario law.
- Contrary Intentions: If you want to exclude certain descendants (e.g., born out of wedlock), specify this in the will.
- Anti-Lapse Rules: Ontario’s Succession Law Reform Act allows gifts to pass to a predeceased beneficiary’s child if no giftover clause exists—but only if the beneficiary is a close relative (e.g., a child or sibling).
4. Practical Tips for Drafting
- Use “Issue” for Generational Flexibility: If you want gifts to flow down family lines automatically, “issue” ensures broader coverage.
- Specify Exclusions/Inclusions: Clearly name stepchildren, foster children, or non-biological descendants if you intend to include or exclude them.
- Update Wills Regularly: Family structures change (e.g., new grandchildren, adoptions). Review your will every 3–5 years or after major life events.
Takeaway
While these terms might seem interchangeable, their legal distinctions can dramatically alter estate outcomes. By defining terms precisely and anticipating family dynamics, you can minimize disputes and ensure your legacy is distributed as intended.
Always consult a lawyer to navigate these nuances effectively. If you need help, feel free to reach out to Peter.
Read More: What If Gene Hackman and Betsy Arakawa Had Lived in Ontario?
Want more information?
Are you interested in a consultation with Peter R. Welsh?
Contact me at Peter@SmartWills.ca
By telephone 416-526-3121
Register for our blog to get valuable tips and up-to-date alerts.
This material is for general information and educational purposes only. Information is based on data gathered from what we believe are reliable sources. It is not guaranteed as to accuracy, does not purport to be complete and is not intended to be used as a primary basis for investment decisions.
